As some of you may already know, I’m currently subletting a quaint apartment on the Plateau for the summer months. I must admit that I’ve grown a certain fondness for the area rather quickly. One of the aspects that I truly adore has to be the typical Plateau architechture with it’s vibrant colours, outdoor staircases, and balconies. But how exactly did this landscape develop? Read on…
Instead of attempting to butcher history and any architechture-related lingo, I’ve opted to mooch off an URBANPHOTO blog post:
They Work On So Many Levels
In Montreal, it’s hard to avoid plexes. Found in almost every neighbourhood, they define the landscape and have made this city what it is today, architecturally, culturally and socially. With their distinct form—several superposed flats, each extending from the front of a building to the back—plexes are a popular form of housing, adaptable to many different lifestyles. But what’s their story? How did Montreal come to be a city of walkup apartments, outdoor staircases and balconies?
According to David Hanna, professor of geography at the Université du Québec à Montréal, the origins of the plex can be traced to a nineteenth century “marriage of convenience” between French and Scottish traditions. Historically, some French-Canadian settlers used outdoor staircases to link the first and second floors of their houses; immigrants from Scotland, meanwhile, brought with them the custom of stacking one flat on top of another. “It kept morphing in the nineteenth century until it settled into the form of an outdoor staircase leading to each apartment,” said Hanna.
Architect Susan Bronson, who teaches at the Université de Montréal, notes that turn-of-the-century building codes, designed to improve living conditions, played a big role in reinforcing the dominance of the plex. In Montreal and the suburb of St. Louis (now Mile End), lot sizes were increased from 20 by 60 feet to 25 by 100 feet and laneways were built in between blocks to service new apartments. Setbacks were mandated on newly-built residential streets, indirectly encouraging the use of outdoor staircases as a space-saving measure.
City regulations also dictated a specific amount of fenestration for each apartment, leading to L-shaped buildings that allowed light in every room. They decreed that wood-frame buildings must be clad in masonry or pressed brick. Crucially, they also insisted that each apartment have its own bathroom, a revolutionary gesture in a city racked by disease, where backyard latrines were still the norm in many old neighbourhoods.
In effect, these regulations created an official template for the plex. Contractors were able to quickly and cheaply build high-quality housing. At the same time, the city’s population swelled with new migrants. “There was a really, really urgent demand for housing,” said Bronson. “A typology developed out of what was essentially a building code.”
Plex layouts remained fundamentally similar from one neighbourhood to the next, but there were nonetheless some regional variations. Imposing, ornate plexes were built on prestigious streets such as St. Hubert St. and St. Joseph Blvd. on the Plateau, and along Sir George Étienne Cartier Sq. in St. Henri. Westmount, Outremont and NDG, meanwhile, “had middle-class pretensions,” explained David Hanna. “They did not want working-class architecture,” so they banned outdoor staircases and tried to disguise plexes as single-family homes, the effect of which can be seen in the twee, semi-detached plexes common in NDG.
Whatever their form, one common element among Montreal plexes has always been their unique ownership structure. Often, the owner lives on the premises, renting out the other flats to help pay off the mortgage. In early 20th century Mile End, this gave immigrants a foothold in the neighbourhood. “When the Jews moved in,” said Bronson, “often an entire family would live on one floor, including aunts and uncles, and then in time their kids would grow up and they would live on upper floors. The same was also true for many Portuguese families” in the 1960s and 70s.
Plexes also presented tenants with an opportunity for home ownership. That was the case for Ylan Luong’s parents, originally from Vietnam, when they moved into the ground floor of a Mile End duplex in the late 1970s. When the owner, who lived upstairs, decided to sell it, he approached her father first. “The guy didn’t even put an ad out or anything, he was just like, ‘Oh, I’m selling, I don’t know if you’re interested,’” she said. Her parents bought the building and started renting out the upstairs apartment.
Luong, a 21-year old nursing student, has lived in her family’s seven-room lower duplex since the day she was born. “It’s pretty crowded in my house because I’ve always had my dog and a cat—I had two dogs at one point—so it’s always very busy,” she said. “And before I had to share my room with my sister. But it’s not bad, my parents like having me close to them.”
As a child, Luong used to play in the back alley. Now, as an adult, she appreciates Mile End’s diverse streetlife. In many ways, plexes, with their balconies and multiplicity of entrances, encourage such activity. “What comes out of this dense urban fabric is a very animated streetlife,” remarked Bronson. In the summer months, Montrealers flock to their balconies, staircases and front gardens, creating what the urbanist Jane Jacobs called “eyes on the street,” the feeling of security that comes from such urban bustle.
Neighbourhoods like Mile End were no longer built after the Second World War, although many modern, automobile-friendly plexes—especially popular with Italian families—were built in 1960s suburbs such as St. Leonard and LaSalle. On the whole, though, the plex was largely abandoned in the late 20th century in favour of detached houses and traditional apartment buildings.
But the plex has made a comeback. The “condoplex,” which combines traditional plex layouts with contemporary architecture, has proliferated across Montreal in recent years. Many even have outdoor staircases. Part of the reason for their popularity with developers, explained Hanna and Bronson, is that they conform easily to housing regulations in boroughs like the Plateau Mont-Royal, which favour buildings that blend in with the existing cityscape, while allowing for the contemporary architecture and modern amenities favoured by homebuyers.
“[Condoplexes] are a recognition of a housing type that works in Montreal,” said Bronson—a housing type that, through its effectiveness and versatility, came to dominate the city.